Rethinking the bonus

I read a great article on how to reshape the traditional bonus. I can’t find the original article, but the study it was based off of was summarized in the Wall Street Journal.

The article went something like this: a bonus is designed to incentive improved performance, and is paid only after certain milestones are achieved. In theory, it works perfectly: the company gets the results it wants, and the employee is paid for going above and beyond.

This structure hasn’t changed significantly for many, many years.

But year end bonus time comes, and companies are often missing their goals despite the promise of a bonus. Is it that the reward was disproportionate to the goal? The goal un-achievable?

Psychologists have long known that the fear of loss was greater than the joy of reward. How then do you apply that to a bonus?

The study gave a group of teachers a bonus at the beginning of the year and told them they had to return it if scores didn’t improve. The other group was rewarded using the traditional bonus structure. The teachers who got the bonus, spent it, and didn’t want to return it improved scores dramatically more than those with the traditional structure.

In my view: brilliant.

Similar Posts

  • Not the same old marketing

    During the first year of leading the Startup Leadership Program, we included the obligatory class on marketing. In the second year, we broke that down into acquiring buyers (entrepreneurial selling) and acquiring users (more akin to traditional marketing). We talked about SEO, retargeting of ads, and virality. It was good stuff, but somehow didn’t seem…

  • Do Well

    A note to the graduates of the Chicago Startup Leadership Program (SLP) 2013, written March 21, 2013. During grad school, rather than wishing students “good luck” on tests, the faculty at Booth would often print the phrase “do well” next to the honor code. Luck is random; acquiring skills to be in a position to take…

  • Best vacation policy ever

    Jason Freedman has it right. He wrote a post recently about 42 Floors vacation policy – which consists of a mandatory two weeks of vacation on your first day. Wait, wha????? That’s right, they start paying you and ask you to show up two weeks later. The premise being that we don’t really take vacation…

  • Brian’s Favorite Articles for July

    People Have Money but Feel Glum—What Does That Mean for the Economy? from the WSJ. A great summary of the juxtaposition between the general malaise in consumer confidence which is contrast to all the strong metrics of the economy (hiring, unemployment, etc). How To Pass On Price Increases Without Alienating Customers – from Forbes Business Council. My favorite quote…

  • Why I Play the Lotto

    As a child, we dream about being astronauts, our backyard tree house becomes an outpost in the Wild West fight between soldiers and Indians, and the only limit to what we can accomplish is chime of mom’s dinner bell (or text message). Somewhere along the way, we start becoming aware of our limitations: our intelligence,…